Tablet Chlorinator Leaking, Clogged or Eating Your Equipment?
How a pool chlorinator fails, why its position on the pad matters, and when to replace it.
pH Of Trichlor Solution
Heater To Check Valve
Starting Dial Setting
CYA Range In ppm
There’s a white plastic canister on the equipment pad with a crust of blue-white powder around the lid and a faint swimming-pool-in-a-closet smell when you open it. Under it, the concrete has a bleached ring. That’s the tablet chlorinator, and on plenty of pads around Camarillo and the rest of the county, it’s the one piece of equipment nobody thinks about until it starts dripping.
A pool chlorinator is simple. Tablets go in, water runs past them, chlorine goes out. The problems come from what that water is like inside the canister, where it’s plumbed, and what happens when the pump shuts off.
Most tablet chlorinator problems are a worn lid O-ring (leaks at the top), mushy or caked tablets (clogs and uneven chlorine), or cracked fittings. The bigger risk is placement: Pentair’s Rainbow feeder manual says the outlet line must be installed after the heater, because concentrated chlorinated water flowing back through a heater can damage it. If your chlorinator feeds into the plumbing before the heater, or has no check valve, fix that before you replace anything else.
Inline or offline: two ways to plumb a pool chlorinator
An inline chlorinator is plumbed directly into the return line, so all or most of the water passes through it. Pentair’s Rainbow 320 is a common inline model.
An offline chlorinator sits beside the plumbing on two small tubes. One tube feeds water in from a fitting on the return line, the other sends chlorinated water back in further down the line. Pentair’s Rainbow 300-29X is an offline model, and offline units are usually what you see on pads where there wasn’t room to put the canister in the pipe.
Neither type is better in every case. What matters more is where the water leaving the chlorinator enters the plumbing, and whether anything stops it from flowing backward.
Why the chlorinator has to sit after the heater
This is the “eating your equipment” part of the title, and it’s not an exaggeration.
Trichlor tablets are strongly acidic. Orenda’s safety data sheet for its trichlor tablets lists a pH of 2.9 to 3.5 for a 1% solution. Jandy’s warranty puts the ideal pool pH at 7.4 to 7.6. Inside a chlorinator, the water sitting on a pile of tablets is far stronger than anything in the pool.
When the pump runs, that water gets diluted by the main flow before it reaches anything. When the pump shuts off, water can drift backward. If the chlorinator outlet is upstream of the heater, the concentrated stuff ends up sitting in the heater’s heat exchanger all night.
Pentair’s Rainbow 300-29X manual is blunt about it: “The outlet line must be installed after the heater.” Jandy’s JXi heater manual says the same from the heater side: plumb chemical feeders downstream of the heater, install an in-line check valve between the heater and the feeder, with a minimum of 18 inches between the heater and the check valve.
Check your warranty before you check your wallet. Jandy’s limited warranty excludes damage from improper use of pool chemicals, and specifically names “introducing chemicals upstream of the heater.” A chlorinator in the wrong spot can turn a covered heater failure into an uncovered one.
If your heater is already showing corrosion and the chlorinator is in the wrong place, our post on whether a pool heater is worth fixing covers the next decision. Just move the chlorinator first, or the new heater gets the same treatment.
The check valve is not optional
Jandy’s JXi manual says to “always install a check valve if there is a chemical feeder installed in the system,” and to take care that there’s no back-siphoning of chemical into the heater, filters or pump. The Pentair manual calls for a one-way, chemically resistant check valve on the discharge line when the feeder sits below water level.
Pentair also says never to put any kind of isolation valve on the discharge or outlet side of the feeder. People add one so they can open the lid without water pouring out. That’s a reasonable idea pointed the wrong way.
A chlorinator in the right spot is boring. A chlorinator in the wrong spot is a heater bill on a slow timer.
Leaks: usually the lid
Most pool chlorinator leaks come from the top. The lid seals on an O-ring, and chlorine is hard on rubber. When the O-ring flattens or cracks, the lid weeps every time the pump is running.
Pentair’s manual is specific about the lubricant: never use oils or grease on the O-ring, and use only the silicone lubricant it names. Petroleum products and concentrated chlorine are a bad pairing. If the lid itself is cracked or the threads are chewed up, the lid gets replaced, not the O-ring.
Leaks at the fittings and tubes on an offline unit are the next most common. Plastic tubing on a pad ages, and the pads in Simi Valley and Moorpark that sit in full afternoon heat are rarely kind to it.
Clogs and uneven chlorine
When tablets get wet and sit with the pump off, they soften. The bottom layer turns to paste and the top layer bridges over it, so the canister looks full but almost nothing is dissolving. Chlorine drops, the pool starts to look tired, and someone turns the dial up.
Pentair’s manual says to keep the inside of the feeder clean of dirt and debris at all times, and to use only clean trichlor tablets. It also says higher numbers on the dial dispense more sanitizer, to start at #3, and to check the chlorine residual daily until you find the right setting for your pool. Daily is the manual’s word, not ours, and it’s a fair hint that a chlorinator isn’t set-and-forget.
Never open a chlorinator with your face over it. Pentair’s manual warns “do not inhale fumes” when removing the cap. Open it slowly at arm’s length, pump off, and let it vent.
What not to put in a tablet chlorinator
Pentair’s manual says, in capital letters, never to mix trichlor or bromine with calcium hypochlorite, and that calcium hypochlorite is not to be used in the feeder in any form. Cal-hypo is the granular shock a lot of people keep in the garage, and it does not belong anywhere near a tablet feeder.
Orenda’s trichlor safety data sheet adds that contact with small amounts of water can produce heat and toxic fumes, and that wet material may generate nitrogen trichloride, which it describes as an explosion hazard. Keep tablets dry, in their original container, and keep anything else out of the canister.
Common pool chlorinator problems at a glance
| What you see | Likely cause | Usual fix |
|---|---|---|
| Drip at the lid | Worn or dry O-ring | New O-ring, silicone lube only |
| Lid won’t seal at all | Cracked lid or threads | Replace lid |
| Wet tubes, crust on fittings | Brittle tubing (offline) | Replace tubes and fittings |
| Full of tablets, low chlorine | Tablets caked or bridged | Clean out, check flow and dial |
| Heater corrosion, white crust inside | Feeder before heater or no check valve | Re-plumb after heater with check valve |
| Canister cracked or stained through | Age and chemical exposure | Replace the chlorinator |
The quiet side effect: cyanuric acid
The chemical name of trichlor on Orenda’s data sheet is trichloroisocyanuric acid. The “cyanuric” part stays in the water after the chlorine is used up. That’s cyanuric acid, or CYA, the stabilizer that protects chlorine from sunlight.
A little is good. Jandy’s warranty lists 30 to 100 ppm as the acceptable CYA range. A pool fed only by tablets keeps adding it, and it doesn’t leave except when water does. Our post on how often a pool should be drained covers what happens when CYA runs high.
Repair it, replace it, or drop it
An O-ring or lid is a repair. A chlorinator with a cracked body, a stained-through canister or fittings that crumble when you touch them is a replacement, and it’s a good time to re-plumb it after the heater with a proper check valve while the pipe is cut anyway.
Some owners skip tablets entirely. A salt system makes chlorine from salt in the water, and our post on whether a saltwater pool is really less maintenance is honest about what that trades. Either way, the chlorinator belongs on the same list as the rest of the pool equipment that actually breaks, because it does.
Asked at the pad, every week
Can I just put tablets in the skimmer instead? We don’t recommend it. That sends strong, acidic water straight through the pump, filter and heater, which is the exact problem a correctly placed chlorinator avoids.
How do I know if mine is before or after the heater? Follow the pipe. Water should go pump, filter, heater, then chlorinator outlet. If the chlorinator outlet enters before the heater, it’s in the wrong spot.
Does a floating tablet dispenser have the same problem? It doesn’t feed into the plumbing, but it can park in one spot and bleach plaster or vinyl. Keep an eye on where it drifts.
Want someone to look at your pad?
Send us a photo of the whole equipment pad through our contact page, with the chlorinator and heater both in the shot. We can usually tell from the plumbing whether it’s in the right spot, and our pool repairs and upgrades cover re-plumbing, chlorinator swaps and check valves.
We service Pentair, Jandy, Zodiac, Hayward and Sta-Rite equipment. Call (805) 586-2055 if it’s dripping right now.
Is your chlorinator in the right spot?
A chlorinator plumbed before the heater can quietly corrode it. We’ll check the order on your pad and fix the leaks while we’re there.
Pump, filter, heater, then chlorine. In that order.
Primary Pool Services – Ventura County
Thousand Oaks · Westlake Village · Agoura Hills · Camarillo · Newbury Park · Simi Valley · Moorpark · Ventura · Oxnard
Story produced with The Final Code.